Founders as an Asset Class
In private markets, investors are accustomed to scrutinising a wide range of investment related factors such as addressable market size, competitive positioning and scalability, spreadsheet model assumptions on customer acquisition costs, gross margins and capital requirements to name but a few. However, behind all the numbers, assumptions and analysis lies a variable that is both harder to quantify and often more decisive: the founder. For investors allocating capital to private companies, recognising founders as an asset class in their own right might be novel but is increasingly essential.
Ideas can pivot, markets evolve and products iterate. However, what often remains unknown (until it is too late) is the founder’s ability to lead through change, be it slow or rapid. Backing the right founder can turn a moderate idea into a breakthrough business. Backing the wrong founder can sink even the most compelling opportunity. As private markets in Australia mature, professional investors are sharpening their focus on leadership assessment, treating it as a core component of due diligence rather than a soft afterthought.
Why the Founder Matters as Much as the Idea
In early-stage investing, the idea is rarely the final product. Atlassian did not begin as a global collaboration software giant, nor did Canva initially resemble the billion-dollar design platform it is today. What early investors who backed Mike Cannon-Brookes, Scott Farquhar and Melanie Perkins recognised at the time, either expressly or implicitly, was not just the size of their potential markets but their ability to execute with discipline.
For investors, the takeaway is clear, the founder’s vision, resilience and leadership capacity often determine whether a business can evolve fast enough to stay relevant. A great founder can pivot in response to feedback or competitive threats. A poor founder can cling to a flawed vision until the money runs out.
How Investors Assess the Human Factor
Evaluating a founder is not simple, but there are recurring dimensions and themes investors now use to guide their judgements.
Resilience and grit. Private markets are littered with stories of rejection and near-failure. Melanie Perkins of Canva endured many, many rejections before securing backing, yet her persistence was exactly what convinced investors she would endure the inevitable challenges of scaling globally from Australia. Investors should ask, has this founder demonstrated an ability to absorb setbacks and continue building?
Scalability of leadership. Some founders thrive in a scrappy start-up but struggle once the company grows and needs systems, governance and professional management. Venture capital firms have often had to step in and replace founders at later stages. The critical question becomes, can this founder lead not just today’s company but the company five years from now?
Ability to attract and retain talent. In resource-constrained start-ups, every hire matters. Investors should observe whether the founder can articulate a mission that inspires employees, whether they surround themselves with complementary skills and whether key staff are committed to staying. A founder who cannot build, motivate and keep a strong team will eventually hit a ceiling, regardless of their personal skill.
Reputation and integrity. In Australia’s relatively tight business ecosystem, word spreads quickly. Founders who over-promise, mistreat staff, or mismanage stakeholders often struggle to raise capital a second time. Conversely, those who demonstrate integrity, even in failed ventures, can retain investor confidence for future projects. Reference checks and informal network conversations are indispensable.
Self-awareness and adaptability. Some of the most investable founders are those who acknowledge their own limitations and surround themselves with people who fill the gaps. Investors should probe whether the founder clings to control or embraces collaboration. Self-awareness is often the difference between a founder who grows with the company and one who stalls its progress.
Australia’s private market ecosystem magnifies the importance of the founder. The domestic market is relatively small, which means successful start-ups often need to internationalise earlier than their US peers. That requires ambition, cultural intelligence and the ability to navigate global capital markets. Atlassian and Canva succeeded not because Australia provided a vast customer base, but because their founders had the vision and resilience to successfully take their products global at an early stage.
Finally, reputation capital is particularly powerful in Australia. With a small pool of entrepreneurs and investors, track records matter greatly. Serial founders can attract strong backing for new ventures and benefit from a credibility premium. For investors, this means assessing not only the founder’s current venture but also their trajectory over time.
Risks of Overlooking the Human Factor
Investors who fixate only on the business model can underestimate the execution risk tied to the founder. A brilliant concept can collapse if the founder lacks discipline, fails to scale leadership, or burns through capital too quickly. Conversely, opportunities may be overlooked if investors fail to spot a founder with exceptional tenacity and adaptability, even if their current idea looks modest.
There is also the risk of bias, both conscious and unconscious. Investors may gravitate toward founders who “look the part”, often young, male and technically trained, while overlooking equally strong leaders from different backgrounds. There are a number of Australian initiatives whose focus is to widen the pipeline and scope of investable founders. Investors must remain alert to their own biases if they want to capture the full diversity dividend.
Treating Founders as an Asset Class
For investors, reframing founders as an asset class means embedding leadership assessment into the heart of investment decisions. This includes:
- Allocating real due diligence time to observing and engaging with founders.
- Using structured tools such as psychometric testing, executive coaching, or scenario planning to stress-test leadership.
- Considering reputational capital alongside financial capital.
- Recognising that a founder’s ability to scale as a leader may be as important as the company’s scalability.
By taking this approach, investors align their capital with the most critical driver of value creation in private markets, namely the people at the helm.
Backing the right founder is not about betting on charisma or gut instinct. It is about disciplined assessment of resilience, leadership, integrity and adaptability. Investors in Australia’s private markets cannot afford to treat the human factor as secondary to the business model. Founders should be viewed as an asset class—central to the investment thesis, inseparable from execution risk and often the decisive variable in returns.
Ideas will shift. Markets will evolve. Products will iterate. But the quality of the founder determines whether capital compounds or dissipates. For investors willing to do the work of evaluating founders with the same rigour they apply to financial models, the rewards can be substantial. In private markets, it is not just the idea that matters, but the person who brings it to life.
PrimaryMarkets
For companies and managed funds that are not listed on a stock exchange, the PrimaryMarkets trading Platform is an ideal way to facilitate the off-market sale of shares in your company and units in managed funds.
PrimaryMarkets is a flexible and evolving Platform that responds in real time to an ever-changing investment environment. In doing so, it provides sophisticated investors with access to companies that are shaping the future in a wide variety of industries and sectors. We provide access to opportunities previously only accessible to institutional investors. In addition to trading, PrimaryMarkets helps companies raise capital from our global investor database.
PrimaryMarkets exemplifies how innovation can transform the way we invest, trade and raise capital by breaking down traditional barriers, providing liquidity solutions and promoting transparency.
As the Platform continues to grow and evolve, it promises to unlock even more opportunities for investors and companies shaping the future of economies.